Create illustrated scrolls that tell the sequence of the story.
One way to do this is with narrative picture scrolls (no words, just pictures, or just "keyword"). Have students draw scenes from a Bible story on a scroll. For younger students this can be as simple as the beginning, middle and end; more details for older students.
Use brown kraft paper or grocery bags, but roll them up several times after illustrating them to give them a "soft and used" feel.
For the ends of the scroll - use dowel sticks or create your own "dowel" by tightly rolling, then taping cylinders of paper to the scroll paper.
Tie the scroll closed with yarn.
Go to a lesson about Joseph's story that uses narrative picture scrolls