Editor's Note: Below we've copied member Heather Fogle's fishing lure photo from the Disciples Art Workshop to this Game Workshop topic and adding a game note about how you can use it. For more related ideas, see the Call of the Disciples Art Workshop posts which have some "fishing" ideas in it.
Disciple "Fishing hooks" made by students for a "fishers of men" game where kids could try and hook different dolls (labeled with different backstories about who they are and why Jesus is calling them) and objects (that had a message or question attached to them for immediate discussion). Have a number of objects that reveal things Jesus doesn't want to call! (such as a bad attitude or selfish person).
Use a real fishing rod or dowel rod with yarn (so the kids can take their "Disciples fishing gear" home with them after the game.