I am hideous at games and only marginal with art, but something with "Love Bears" comes to mind. (Verse 7 - Love bears all things, etc)
Maybe make 3 bears - Faith, Hope and Love - the Love bear would be larger than the other two, because it is the "greatest".
Or maybe a board game with situations, and small bears for markers. Players would move forward for showing a loving action, backward if they did not.