How about a version of the old 'Gong Show'? I know that I'm dating myself but I'm sure some of you must remember it. It could be combined with a talent show, both adult and kids doing silly things, rotten things, secular stuff. The rest of the kids could 'gong' or cheer based on the scripture.
Makes stuffed bears for 'love bears all things'. Love the bear could have his name on a shirt. Alternately this could be done as a group Banner or wall hanging with the 3 bears mentioned above.
Draw a picture or design on heavy cardboard with crayon. Use a toothpick to scrap off some of the crayon in a pattern, small hearts or crosses works well. Add scripture printed of the computer if desired. Frame.