Salt dough ornament stars
make the ornaments in advance; here is a blog with instructions and pictures showing the steps http://frugalfemmecarole.blogs...now-let-it-snow.html
During class the kids can paint and glitter the ornaments while you talk about the story after reading the scripture. The picture from the blog is snowflakes, but stars could be done in a similar manner:
These are the Williams Sonoma pie crust cutters that she used. (I think they look sort of like stars)
But Williams Sonoma also has a set with a star. (The presses that leave the dents make them more interesting to paint than plain flat cookies.)